Reviews

The Big Match
by Julian Pottage

Batsford £13.20 inc p&p from the Mr Bridge Mail Order Service
Tel: 01672 519219 (code BK30)

In the world of cinema it often happens that a new film is a remake of some classic from two or three decades ago. In the same way Julian Pottage's latest book, Win the Big Match, follows a theme used in several books written by the great Hugh Kelsey in the 1980s. You, the reader, are playing in a Gold Cup final and are tested on sixty-four deals. There is an opportunity to 'score up' after each set and to see if you eventually win the match.

Pottage is an accurate analyst with the valuable knack of recognising an interesting deal. I found his selection of deals first-class. They were fairly difficult to solve, mind you, and average club players might find themselves out of their depth. Test yourself on Deal 15. (Only the North-South hands are initially displayed in the book.)

    K Q J 10
  10 7 3 2
  K 4
  K Q 2
 
  7 5
  A J 8 4
  A Q 10 8 2
  J 6
  9 6 4
  Q 9 6
  J 6
  10 8 7 4 3
    A 8 3 2
  K 5
  9 7 5 3
  A 9 5

West
Lucy
North
Pat
East
Suzanne
South
You
      Pass
1 Dbl Pass 2
Pass 2 Pass 2
Pass 4 End  

How would you play the spade game on a trump lead?

Pottage explains that you have eight top tricks, including one for the K, and therefore need two ruffs to bring the total to ten. It is better to try for heart ruffs, rather than diamond ruffs, because North has the entries and you do not want to ruff with North's master trumps. Suppose you play a heart to the king at trick two. West will win and play another trump. East can then win the second heart and draw yet another trump. You will score only one heart ruff and go down. The solution is to duck a round of hearts! Now West has to win the second heart and will have no trump to play. Well, that's a great deal, I'm sure you agree.

Although the book was technically excellent, I did not get much added pleasure from the setting. Your partner, Pat, is deliberately left amorphous so the reader can visualise either a male or female. Every time I read such as 'If Lucy has three diamonds' I had to look back to the bidding table to see if Lucy was West or East. I preferred Kelsey's use of a mere 'East' or 'West'. Also, details such as 'Suzanne dips into her bag for some pumpkin seeds and pops a few into her mouth. Then she ruffs with the 9.' seemed contrived and not in keeping with the atmosphere of a Gold Cup final. Still, this is a splendid collection of deals and there is much to be learnt from a close perusal of the material.

David Bird

 

© Bridge Plus 1999-2006

Disclaimer Privacy Policy